• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Articles
  • News
  • Events
  • Advertize
  • Jobs
  • Courses
  • Contact
  • (0)
  • LoginRegister
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS
      Articles
      News
      Events
      Job Posts
    • Twitter
Datafloq

Datafloq

Data and Technology Insights

  • Categories
    • Big Data
    • Blockchain
    • Cloud
    • Internet Of Things
    • Metaverse
    • Robotics
    • Cybersecurity
    • Startups
    • Strategy
    • Technical
  • Big Data
  • Blockchain
  • Cloud
  • Metaverse
  • Internet Of Things
  • Robotics
  • Cybersecurity
  • Startups
  • Strategy
  • Technical

Analysis: In Apple vs Epic Games, battle of the experts gets personal

Reuters / 3 min read.
May 13, 2021
floq.to/z0Vt5

By Stephen Nellis and Paresh Dave

SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) – In its ongoing case against Apple Inc, “Fortnite” creator Epic Games is counting on this week’s testimony from its star expert witness David Evans, chairman of Global Economics Group, to make its case that Apple is an anticompetitive monopolist over app developers.

Apple has called its own experts to rebut Evans’ views on the market, but with an added personal twist: It called MIT economist Richard Schmalensee, who has authored numerous books and academic papers together with Evans, to accuse Evans of contradicting his own prior research.

Legal experts said Apple’s aim was to chip away at Evans’ credibility in the eyes of the judge who will rule on the case.

The erstwhile collaborators – who together have written works cited extensively by the U.S. Supreme Court in landmark antitrust decisions – are duking it out over the central issue in the three-week trial in federal court in Oakland, California: What is the relevant market in the case?

Framed Epic’s way, Apple and its app store are a monopoly that is abusing control over the mobile software market to extract commissions for payments made inside apps. But Apple argues that it is just one of many competitors in a healthy market for video game purchases.

Whichever side prevails in persuading Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers on the question of market definition will likely win the entire case, antitrust experts said.

“Epic absolutely has to win the market definition,” said Daniel Lyons, a professor at Boston College Law School. “If Apple is right that ‘Fortnite’ on iOS is just one small part of the larger ‘Fortnite’ universe, then Apple doesn’t have market power and anything they do is unlikely to cause consumer harm because consumers can switch.”

On the stand this week, Evans testified that Apple is what is known as a single-brand market, arguing that once consumers buy an iPhone, the costs of switching to an Android are so high that they rarely make the jump.

Since about 2010, Evans testified, Apple’s App Store has effectively been its own market, and users rarely venture outside. After Apple kicked “Fortnite” off the App Store, Evans testified, only a small fraction of Apple users jumped to other devices like PCs or gaming consoles to play “Fortnite.”

Schmalensee, by contrast, contends that the relevant market is gaming transactions, where Apple is just one platform among many – Microsoft Corp’s Xbox and Sony Group Corp’s PlayStation – sitting between game developers and gamers and charging commissions to facilitate transactions.

Apple’s App Store is a two-sided marketplace, Schmalensee testified, a concept that he and Evans have written about extensively, including in an amicus curiae brief on behalf of American Express in a 2018 U.S. Supreme Court case.

American Express had prohibited merchants from steering their customers toward rival cards with lower swipe fees, arguing that its higher fees helped fund cardholder perks that benefited consumers. The court sided with American Express, citing Evans and Schmalensee extensively in its decision.

Schmalensee said Apple’s rules that prohibit apps from steering consumers to less costly payment presented an almost identical issue, and that Evans had contradicted many aspects of his previous work.

Outside observers have been surprised by the split between the two star economists.

“I would say (Evans’) views on AmEx haven’t changed, but what he would say is the facts here are different and so the same result isn’t appropriate,” said Geoff Manne, president and founder of the International Center for Law & Economics research center. “Personally, I don’t see how he gets there and gets it to stick.”

Part of Apple’s strategy in putting Schmalensee on the stand was to bring up the differences between Evans’ previous work and his current view of the Epic case in a bid to make his testimony look less credible, observers said.

‘Each of them knows though that whatever opinions they have said in the past have to be consistent with what they say now,” said Steven Salop, professor of economics and law at Georgetown University and a self-described consultant to Epic on its case.

Schmalensee declined to comment, and Evans did not immediately return requests for comment.

(Reporting by Stephen Nellis in San Francisco and Paresh Dave in Oakland, California; Editing by Jonathan Weber and Leslie Adler)

Categories: News
Tags: BI, costs, mobile, research, strategy

About Reuters

Primary Sidebar

E-mail Newsletter

Sign up to receive email updates daily and to hear what's going on with us!

Publish
AN Article
Submit
a press release
List
AN Event
Create
A Job Post

Jobs

  • Software Engineer | South Yorkshire, GB - February 07, 2023
  • Software Engineer with C# .net Investment House | London, GB - February 07, 2023
  • Senior Java Developer | London, GB - February 07, 2023
  • Software Engineer – Growing Digital Media Company | London, GB - February 07, 2023
  • LBG Returners – Senior Data Analyst | Chester Moor, GB - February 07, 2023
More Jobs
Host your website with Managed WordPress for $1.00/mo with GoDaddy!

Tags

AI Amazon analysis analytics app application Artificial Intelligence BI Big Data business China Cloud Companies company costs crypto customers Data design development digital environment experience future Google+ government information learning machine learning market mobile Musk news Other public research sales security share social social media software strategy technology twitter

News

  • Exclusive-SEC collects Wall Street’s private messages as WhatsApp probe escalates -sources
  • Prices tumble for cobalt used for electric vehicle batteries
  • Nissan says all new models coming to Europe will be fully electric
  • German transport minister rejects punitive tariffs in EU’s China EV probe
  • Apple supplier Pegatron halts iPhone assembly at India plant after fire
More News

Related Online Courses

  • Oracle Cloud Data Management Foundations Workshop
  • Data Science at Scale
  • Statistics with Python
More courses

Footer


Datafloq is the one-stop source for big data, blockchain and artificial intelligence. We offer information, insights and opportunities to drive innovation with emerging technologies.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Recent

  • 5 Reasons Why Modern Data Integration Gives You a Competitive Advantage
  • 5 Most Common Database Structures for Small Businesses
  • 6 Ways to Reduce IT Costs Through Observability
  • How is Big Data Analytics Used in Business? These 5 Use Cases Share Valuable Insights
  • How Realistic Are Self-Driving Cars?

Search

Tags

AI Amazon analysis analytics app application Artificial Intelligence BI Big Data business China Cloud Companies company costs crypto customers Data design development digital environment experience future Google+ government information learning machine learning market mobile Musk news Other public research sales security share social social media software strategy technology twitter

Copyright © 2023 Datafloq
HTML Sitemap| Privacy| Terms| Cookies

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp

In order to optimize the website and to continuously improve Datafloq, we use cookies. For more information click here.

Dear visitor,
Thank you for visiting Datafloq. If you find our content interesting, please subscribe to our weekly newsletter:

Did you know that you can publish job posts for free on Datafloq? You can start immediately and find the best candidates for free! Click here to get started.

Not Now Subscribe

Thanks for visiting Datafloq
If you enjoyed our content on emerging technologies, why not subscribe to our weekly newsletter to receive the latest news straight into your mailbox?

Subscribe

No thanks

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.

Marketing cookies

This website uses Google Analytics to collect anonymous information such as the number of visitors to the site, and the most popular pages.

Keeping this cookie enabled helps us to improve our website.

Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!